Mind · 5 min read ·
Lost and regained three times? Why it happens, and what's different when the weight finally stays off.
If you have 30 seconds
- 1The weight often comes back because the diet ends while your body tends to burn less.
- 2After a strict diet, hunger can stay high for months.
- 3What lasts is what you can keep doing: slow loss, strength training and maintenance.
You lost eight kilos before summer and put them back on by Christmas, plus two more. That's yo-yo dieting, and some people have been through it three times.
'I've lost the weight three times and regained it every time' is something I hear a lot. Then comes the fear of a 'broken metabolism'. Your body adapts. It doesn't break. And willpower usually has little to do with it.
How to spot yo-yo dieting
- Each time you lose a bit less. The diet from five years ago may now work less well and leave you hungrier.
- It comes back faster than it went. It takes months to lose and sometimes only weeks to regain.
- You live like an on-off switch. You're on a diet or eating 'normally', with nothing in between.
Why the weight comes back after a diet
When you eat far less for months, your body reacts as if food were scarce and defends itself.
It burns less. You weigh less, you tend to move less without noticing, and your body wastes less energy. This can last months, and 'eating like before' may be too much.
It gets hungrier. Your hunger hormone tends to rise and your fullness hormone to fall, and they can stay that way after the diet, even once your weight is stable.
Fat comes back first. If the weight returns quickly, it tends to be mostly fat, often around your belly. For example, you lose five kilos, three fat and two lean mass. You regain five, and four are fat.
The diet was built to end. Two or three months of rigid rules, then you went back to how you ate before. None of those diets told you how to eat at a restaurant or on a work trip. And all-or-nothing diets are often linked to bingeing and guilt.
The diets you've done worked. Nobody prepared you for what comes after.
How do you stop yo-yo dieting?
By planning what comes next before you start. Lose slowly, protect your muscle and, when you reach the weight you want, stay there for a few months while eating more.
Go slowly. Aim for 0.4 to 0.8 per cent of your weight a week. The article on losing fat without losing muscle explains why. The harsher the cut, the harder your body usually fights back.
Protect your muscle. Two strength sessions a week and protein at every meal, during the loss and after. In one comparison, more than seven in ten people who had kept the weight off were still training, compared with fewer than three in ten among those who had regained it.
Put the free meal in the plan. Dinner out is planned, and the next day you're back to your usual meals, with no fasting to compensate.
End the diet gradually, then hold the weight. When the loss is over, increase your portions step by step, checking weight and waist once a week. After that, a maintenance phase at least as long as the loss usually helps: the same training, more food. Your body needs time to stop defending itself, and you need time to make it a habit.
Try this
0 of 5 done
Your ticks are saved on this device.
Test yourself
You've reached your target weight after four months. What do you do from Monday?
If you've regained the weight three times, you know how to lose it. This time, write the plan starting from the end: what you'll eat and how you'll train once the scales show your target number.


